Paver patio that replaced an old concrete patio in Livingston, Essex County, NJ

    Pavers vs. Concrete in Totowa, NJ: Which Holds Up Better Here?

    It's one of the first questions we get on almost every estimate. Should the new patio, walkway, or driveway be pavers or concrete? It's a fair question, and the honest answer used to be "it depends on your budget." On our jobs today, that's mostly not the deciding factor anymore.

    We're Masonry Pro Construction, a family company and masonry contractor in Totowa. Biagio has more than 35 years in the trade, and his son Gino runs the jobs in the field. We install both. This page lays out how they actually compare in North Jersey, and why we end up recommending pavers most of the time. For how we build a patio from the ground up, see our page on paver patio installation in Totowa.

    The Price Gap Is Smaller Than You'd Think

    Paver patio that replaced an old concrete patio in Livingston, Essex County, NJ

    Most people assume concrete is the cheap option and pavers are the splurge. On our North Jersey jobs, they often land in the same range. Driveways are a good example: concrete and paver driveways both generally run about $18 to $30 per square foot for us.

    What moves the price on either one is the same list: tearing out the old surface, access to the yard, base prep, drainage, and the finish or paver you pick. A plain broom finish slab is cheaper than stamped concrete, and a basic paver costs less than a premium one. Compare like with like, and the gap gets small.

    So if the price is close, the better question is how each one holds up here.

    What North Jersey Winters Do to Each One

    Our winters are hard on anything outdoors. The northern part of the state sees long cold stretches, with the ground freezing and thawing over and over1. Water gets into small gaps, freezes, expands, and pushes. Add road salt, and the surface takes a beating.

    A concrete slab is one big piece. When the ground under it moves, it cracks. Control joints help decide where it cracks, but they don't stop it.

    Pavers are hundreds of small pieces locked together on a compacted stone base2. When the ground moves a little, the pavers move with it instead of snapping. If a spot does settle, it shows as a small dip, not a crack running across the whole surface.

    When Something Goes Wrong, Pavers Are Easier to Fix

    Paver patio around a pool in Kinnelon, Morris County, NJ

    This is the biggest difference, and the one most people don't think about until they need it.

    If a corner of a paver patio settles, we lift the pavers in that section, fix the base underneath, and put the same pieces back. When we're done, it matches, because it's the same pavers.

    Concrete doesn't work that way. A crack can be patched, but the patch almost never matches. Stamped concrete is the hardest of all. Matching the color and pattern of an old stamped slab is tough, so a repair tends to stand out. That's one of the main reasons homeowners call us to switch to pavers.

    Should You Tear Out Cracked Stamped Concrete?

    Not always. When someone calls about a cracked stamped patio, we check a few things first:

    • Did the slab shift? If sections have dropped or tilted, the base underneath has moved.
    • Are the edges uneven? Cracks that leave a lip can be a trip hazard.
    • Where does the water go? If water pools against the house, that's a bigger problem than how the patio looks.

    A small surface crack may only need a local repair. If sections have settled, or water is running toward the foundation, replacing it lets us fix the slope and the drainage at the same time. That's usually when switching to pavers makes the most sense.

    One Look From the Driveway to the Front Door

    Paver walkway and steps with a matching border in North Jersey

    Pavers also give you more control over how the whole property looks. You pick a color and style that suits the house, then carry the same border from the driveway to the walkway to the front steps. Everything ties together.

    In Wayne, for example, an old concrete pool deck came out and Cambridge pavers went in, with Techo-Bloc coping around the existing pool and several sets of steps tying the levels together. In Livingston, an old concrete patio was replaced with a bigger one in Cambridge pavers, with a step added along one side to handle the slope.

    When Concrete Still Makes Sense

    Pavers aren't the answer for every homeowner. Some people simply like the clean look of a smooth concrete slab, and that's a fine choice. We install both, and we'll tell you straight which one fits your job.

    Common Questions About Pavers vs. Concrete in North Jersey

    Are pavers more expensive than concrete in New Jersey?

    Often not by much. On our North Jersey jobs, concrete and paver driveways both generally run about $18 to $30 per square foot. The finish, tear-out, access, and base prep move the price on either one.

    Do pavers or concrete hold up better in NJ winters?

    Pavers usually do. A concrete slab is one piece, so it cracks when the ground moves. Pavers sit on a compacted stone base and move a little with the ground instead of cracking.

    Can you repair a paver patio without it looking patched?

    Yes. We lift the pavers in the problem area, fix the base, and put the same pieces back, so the repair matches.

    Can cracked stamped concrete be repaired?

    A small surface crack can often get a local repair. Matching the color and pattern of old stamped concrete is hard, though. If sections have settled or water pools near the house, replacing it lets us fix the slope and drainage.

    Can my driveway, walkway, and steps match?

    Yes. With pavers, you can pick one color and style and carry the same border from the driveway to the walkway to the front steps.

    Not Sure Which One Fits Your Yard?

    We'll come out, look at what you have, and give you a straight answer on pavers or concrete for your project. Free on site estimates across Bergen, Passaic, Essex, and Morris counties. To see how we build a paver patio start to finish, visit our page on paver patios in Totowa.

    Masonry Pro Construction is family owned, fully licensed, and insured, NJ HIC License #13VH06777200.

    Ready to Get Started?

    If you've got a project you've been putting off, or something that needs attention now, we're here to help. No pressure, just honest advice.

    Need A Mason Contractor? Request An Estimate!

    Fill out the form and we'll get back to you promptly.

    Note: Without SMS consent we will only be able to reach you by phone call or email.

    * Required. Good details now mean an honest, accurate estimate later.

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.